That was then this is now. I've seen this argument the last couple seasons. And in ways he is not, his arm strength is mediocre he is not the fleetest of foot But he makes up for those eroding skills with probably the best reader of defenses the league has seen.  He has made some inferior receiver talent look pretty good cause if they get open they get the ball and unlike his counterpart Peyton he doesn't get happy feet and start making bad decisions when his O-line is overwhelmed But I'd only rate Rodgers over him (and by a fairly big margin). Peyton as usual through their careers is neck and neck with Tom. Brees is no longer elite the only ones I see possibly joining this small group are Luck and Wilson and they are still a couple of years away from joining that argument anyways.